Post
by miftah » Tue Oct 31, 2006 4:05 pm
So, my addendum re: the show.
Placebo were alright. Their performance and the musicianship were outstanding. The only problem is that their catalog lacks any lasting impact. Their songs are vapor and given to be forgotten as soon as they end.
She Wants Revenge shouldn't bother with trying to play live. Contrived and at times embarrassing. As thin as the songs are on record, they appear hollow and pointless in concert. Everything that bugged me about them before only began to grate on me this time. Though its nice that someone wants to keep the spirit of '83 alive, they don't remind me of Depeche or any of the pioneers of that era. Instead they sound like knock offs of third-generation also-rans like Red Flag and Real Life, only even more diluted. Making reference to a girl masturbating or expressing her masochism is hardly daring or even remotely controversial. Its merely the means for a lot of the Black Cotton Mafia to drape their fantasies on. If either the band or its fans were to actually enter a BDSM club, they'd need therapy for years afterward. When they finished the show with a crowd participation sing-along of "Tear You Apart" I was literally embarrassed for them. Maybe if VNV Nation were to cozy up to Fred Durst, they could have a radio hit too.
Any authenticity I was missing in She Wants Revenge, I found in spades in Social Distortion. If you know the band at all, you know what they delivered. What She Wants Revenge attempt in their intentionally depressing music and fail, I genuinely find in SD. An uptempo rock song like "I Was Wrong" will literally move me to tears, because I've been there and I know he knows what he's talking about. I really wish the show would have been on their own, though, and in a bar with a good solid 21+ policy because the high school punks were virtually unendurable. I know you have to encourage the kids to dig good music and because of that, I tend to forgive their transgressions. They're gonna be amped-up little monkeys. But damn, this band is good enough to sit and watch, and that was a little hard to do while the young bucks were knockin' racks. Good to see them such a draw and you could tell they made a lot of new fans that night.
"Fear of the bee means the honey is for me" - Jhonn Balance